Bread · Intermediate
Jake's Whole-Wheat Sandwich Bread
A soft, honey-sweetened, Dave's Killer Bread-inspired sandwich loaf made with freshly milled whole wheat, an overnight flour soak, olive oil, butter, vital wheat gluten, and soy lecithin. Designed for fluffy, kid-friendly sandwiches and improved storage.
Earlier seeded loaf tested · current seed-free revision untested.
Ingredient amounts scale with the batch size. Time estimates stay as written; use the recipe's texture and doneness cues.
Let's make it
Method
Soak the freshly milled flour overnight
8–12 hours, previously instructedThe evening before mixing the dough, combine 700 g with 500 g until no dry flour remains. Cover and rest overnight. The successful batch used an overnight flour-and-water soak rather than the earlier daytime refrigerator fermentation. Room-temperature overnight soaking was the recorded method, although a cooler or refrigerated soak may be preferable for a repeatable schedule.
Activate the yeast
5–10 minutesMix 11 g with 30 g at approximately 100–105°F and 15 g. Allow to stand until foamy. This is the latest proposed yeast-water quantity for the batch that already contained 500 g water. For a future batch targeting 500 g total water, reserve 30 g from the overnight water instead.
Combine the dough ingredients
Approximately 5 minutes, estimatedAdd the activated yeast mixture, 45 g, 60 g, 12 g, 30–35 g, and 10 g to the soaked flour. Include 50 g if keeping oats in the recipe. Mix until combined. Soy lecithin is a proposed addition and has not yet been verified in a finished loaf.
Knead thoroughly
Approximately 20 minutes in mixer plus 5 minutes by hand, recordedKnead with a stand mixer until the dough develops elasticity and strength. The successful batch required approximately 20 minutes of mixer kneading. Incorporate 28 g gradually in small pieces during kneading. The successful batch remained very sticky, so additional vital wheat gluten and as needed were added gradually. The exact added flour amount was not measured. Finish with approximately 5 minutes of hand kneading. Aim for cohesive, elastic dough that can be handled and shaped; do not assume it must completely release from the bottom of the mixer bowl.
First room-temperature proof
Approximately 1 hour 30 minutesCover the dough and let it rise on the counter at approximately 71°F until roughly doubled. The successful batch did not use a daytime refrigerator rise.
Divide and shape the loaves
Approximately 10–15 minutes, estimatedDivide the dough for 2 loaves into equal portions. Roll each portion out with a rolling pin, fold, and roll into a loaf-shaped cylinder. Avoid excessive repeated rolling if the dough becomes tight and resistant. Place seam-side down in greased 9 × 5-inch loaf pans. The latest version omits sunflower, pumpkin, chia, and sesame seeds.
Second room-temperature proof
Approximately 2 hours 30 minutes to 3 hours, recordedCover the pans with a damp towel and let rise at approximately 71°F. In the successful batch, the loaves rose slowly and were left for about 2.5–3 hours until they appeared near their maximum height. The poke test seemed satisfactory earlier, but the user continued proofing because the loaves had not reached the desired height. Judge readiness by the dough's expansion and ability to retain its shape rather than waiting indefinitely for a fixed height.
Bake using the successful cold-oven method
Approximately 30–32 minutes recorded; longer bake proposed but untestedPlace both loaf pans in a cold oven and set to 325°F. In the successful bake, the pans were rotated or repositioned after approximately 20 minutes because their adjacent inner edges browned faster. The plain loaf reached approximately 200°F internal temperature after about 30 minutes total, including oven warm-up. The slightly larger seeded loaf required about 2 additional minutes. A later 35–37-minute bake and 205–208°F target were suggested for improved sandwich storage but were not tested. Use internal temperature and appearance to judge doneness rather than relying solely on time.
Cool, slice, and store
Until completely cool; exact duration not recordedRemove loaves from the pans and cool completely on a wire rack before slicing or bagging. For school lunches, slice and freeze portions once cooled if desired. Avoid sealing bread while warm. Freezing and revised storage practices were recommendations, not confirmed successful results from this conversation.
From my kitchen
Notes for next time
Show notes
From my kitchen
Notes for next time
Successful earlier bake
User reported that the bread came out beautifully after overnight soaking, approximately 20 minutes of mixer kneading, another 5 minutes of hand kneading, a 1.5-hour room-temperature first proof, a 2.5–3-hour second proof, and a cold-oven bake at 325°F. The result was substantially better than previous squat, dense loaves.
Earlier hydration failure
The original formula used approximately 720 g whole wheat flour and 720 g water, plus potentially additional yeast-proofing water. The dough was extremely sticky, spread rather than holding its shape, and collapsed easily. The later 500 g water formula performed better, although extra flour was still needed.
Successful batch flour adjustments
During the successful bake, the user added approximately one extra tablespoon of vital wheat gluten, followed by an unmeasured quantity of white flour. The dough improved but never fully stopped sticking to the mixer bowl. This means the exact successful formula cannot yet be reproduced entirely by weight.
Butter addition
Approximately one-quarter stick of softened butter was added incrementally during kneading. The user associated this technique with a silkier dough. Its individual effect was not isolated from the other adjustments.
Shaping observations
The dough became noticeably tough and resistant after repeated rolling and folding. The user stopped manipulating it at that point. A short rest before further shaping may help in future batches, but that adjustment was not tested.
Original seeded variation
The successful batch was divided into two loaves. Both contained rolled oats, but only one received chia, pumpkin, and sunflower seeds. Earlier documented quantities were 1 tablespoon chia, 40 g pumpkin seeds, and 40 g sunflower seeds, although the user did not confirm these exact amounts for the successful batch. The seeded loaf was slightly larger and baked approximately 2 minutes longer.
Family feedback
The children disliked the seeds, so the latest version eliminates them. The family also reported that homemade bread did not hold up well for peanut butter and jelly sandwiches prepared in the morning and eaten at school lunch, becoming soggier than commercial sandwich bread.
Soy lecithin experiment
The latest recipe adds 10 g soy lecithin powder to improve dough handling, crumb softness, and resistance to staling. No completed bake or family tasting with soy lecithin was documented. Lecithin is not a guaranteed barrier against moisture from jelly.
Latest flour and water amounts
The newest batch had already been started with 700 g freshly milled whole wheat flour and 500 g water, instead of the earlier 720 g flour. The last yeast guidance suggested another 30 g water, bringing this batch to 530 g total water if followed. The user did not confirm whether that additional water was actually used.
Yeast evolution
The recipe began with 7 g yeast, later increased to 9–10 g because the user wanted faster rising. The user subsequently reported using 11 g. This latest amount is preserved, but its isolated effect on rise and final crumb was not established.
Earlier baking observations
The user tried baking without preheating and reported that the successful cold-oven bake at 325°F took approximately 30 minutes to reach 200°F internally. The oven reportedly runs hot, and rotating the side-by-side loaves helped address uneven browning.
Unverified storage recommendations
Suggestions included cooling completely, freezing sliced bread, placing peanut butter on both bread slices before adding jelly, and possibly baking somewhat longer. These were not tested and should not be presented as established improvements. Lowering dough hydration was also proposed for a future trial but was not incorporated into the latest already-started batch.
Overnight soak clarification
The user explicitly confirmed that the successful batch included the overnight flour-and-water soak. Only the daytime refrigerated proof was omitted. The earlier recipe incorrectly suggested adding the yeast-proofing water on top of the full water quantity without consistently accounting for hydration.
Recipe version
This entry documents the latest proposed seed-free formula alongside confirmed observations from the earlier successful seeded bake. It should remain marked as a revision awaiting testing rather than a fully validated final formula.
Along the way
Recipe photos
Photos from the cooking process and finished dish.